This book
presents a collection of virtually unedited stories from the Nebraska
WPA files, supplemented by a few previously published narratives and
a few others the editor collected more recently. They are stories
about a long-dead art -- horse-trading -- and, therefore, illuminate
a little-studied facet of American folk culture. Along with Welsch's
introductory essay, incisive head-notes and very necessary glossary
of the traders' jargon, they provide a clear picture of not only the
techniques of horse-trading, but also the psychology of it. One sees,
clearly and soon, that profit was often a less important impetus,
for instance, than was success -- frequently identified as "skinnin'"
one's opponent. The traders' joy lay in the game -- in the elaborate
rituals of bargaining, in the sometimes complex set-ups, in the excitement
of the escape.
The narrator
of many of these stories is Lew Croughan, himself a horse-trader,
and his stories evidence quite clearly that his profession was more
a calling than a mere livelihood. He says, for example, in "The Reverend
Finmore's Slightly Excitable Mare," "This was going to be an extraordinary
experience. . . ."(p.27) Another narrative begins "There was not much
fun in being too serious in a trade . . ."(p. 180). And in another
Croughan says, "[Horse traders] were always ambitious to out-do one
another. . . " (p. 182). In short, though there is much talk of profit,
these other elements overshadow it.
This calling,
we see, had a code of its own: traders could cheat buyers, for instance,
but must also take it in stride when they were themselves cheated.
And, though they were not obliged to be truthful, neither could they
lie outright -- a circumstance that made the ambiguous term the main
tool of their trade. Likewise, though it was permissible to steal
corn from a farmer, it was bad form to cast blame on another in doing
so.
Mister,
You Got Yourself A Horse is a clear and careful presentation
of the horse-trading profession. It also gives glimpses of life on
the Great Plains in the 1880s and 90s, glimpses into religion and
work and entertainment, and glimpses into the often grubby human character.
Too, it is an entertaining work to read. The stories are generally
well-told and humorous. Thus, one can learn much from it -- and have
fun in the process.
Welsch's
introductory essay provides an overview of the profession and its
place in the culture, and useful commentary on the materials, methods
and informants. While the work doesn't directly involve Missouri lore,
it does suggest an area of folk :culture that ought to be researched
in Missouri. It also suggests to me that Missouri's contemporary "horse-traders,"
those maverick car dealers who buy used cars for resale, ought to
be studied in a like manner.
Though I
saw little point to the chapter divisions, neither did they damage
the book. It is, all in all, a good book, well worth the price for
either folklorists or general readers; of course, I've never seen
anything by Roger Welsch that wouldn't be.
Jim Vandergriff
Springfield,
MO